South America Squared, 1967

Frank Bowling
South America Squared, 1967
Acrylic on canvas, 243 x 274 cm
Rennie Collection, Vancouver
© VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2017


The international symposium 5-plus-1: Rethinking Abstraction is held in celebration of the Sharjah Art Foundation opening of the travelling exhibition Frank Bowling: Mappa Mundi, which was inaugurated earlier this year at Haus der Kunst, Munich, Germany and travelled to the Irish Museum of Modern Art (IMMA), Dublin, Ireland. The exhibition was curated by Okwui Enwezor with Anna Schneider at Haus der Kunst. The Sharjah presentation is co-curated by Hoor Al Qasimi and Okwui Enwezor with Anna Schneider.

The one-day symposium, featuring new and original papers, will focus on the implications of the original 5-plus-1 exhibition, curated by Frank Bowling in 1969, making reference to the five artists who joined him in the exhibition: sculptors Melvin Edwards and Daniel Johnson and painters Al Loving, Jack Whitten and William T. Williams. Bowling, the ‘plus-1’, questioned the role of art in society and the function of abstraction.

In his career of six decades, Bowling’s engagement with history, migration, memory and representation has continuously expanded the conception of what painting can be and for whom it is created. When he turned to activism in 1967, Bowling shifted away from the speculative realism of the figure, which underpinned his earlier work, and imagined a sensorial and visceral experience of painting, not only encompassing lived experience, but also invoking memory, absence, loss and exile. Revisiting the 5-plus-1 exhibition in this symposium becomes particularly significant in light of the rising interest in abstraction today as demonstrated by recent retrospectives and other exhibitions of work by abstract artists of African descent such as Sam Gilliam, Jack Whitten, Melvin Edwards and Alma Thomas, among others. To contribute to this ongoing conversation, this symposium brings some of the major figures in Bowling’s 1969 exhibition together with a younger generation of scholars, artists and art critics to provide a platform for documentation and critical investigation of such a paramount period.

Historically, the relationship between black artists who engaged with abstraction as a genre of painting or sculpture and those who preferred figuration as a mode of expression has been, at best, contentious. Figuration was preferred during the Black Arts Movement as a strong expression of the experience of racism and the struggle for justice and equality, while abstraction was viewed as less expressive of those realities and catering to Euro-American tastes. Yet, despite the dominance of figurative art, many black artists who were involved in the struggle and committed to activism did engage with abstraction to varying degrees. Thus, the symposium will provide an opportunity for participants to focus on the historical tensions between abstraction and figuration in African Diaspora/black art and the debates around the issue.

One facet of scholarship that remains scarce is work on important black women artists, such as Alma Thomas, Betty Blayton and Mildred Thompson, who contributed to the practice of and discussions surrounding abstraction. The symposium will enable a critical investigation of abstraction in light of its gender dynamics from both historical and contemporary perspectives.
Symposium convenors are Hoor Al Qasimi (President and Director, Sharjah Art Foundation), Okwui Enwezor (curator, critic, and former director of Haus der Kunst) and Salah M. Hassan (Goldwin Smith Professor and Director, Institute for Comparative Modernities (ICM), Cornell University).


Participants include Hoor Al Qasimi, Benjamin Bowling (professor), Frank Bowling (artist), Melvin Edwards (artist), Salah M. Hassan, Kellie Jones (Professor in Art History and Archaeology and Faculty Fellow, Institute for Research in African American Studies, Columbia University), Courtney J. Martin (Deputy Director and Chief Curator, Dia Art Foundation), Gilane Tawadros (Chief Executive, DACS and Vice Chair, Stuart Hall Foundation), Krista Thompson (Mary Jane Crowe Chair in Art History, Northwestern University) and Zoe Whitley (Curator, International Art, Tate Modern).


To register please click here.

  • Schedule

    To download the full schedule please click here.

    10:00 am: Registration
    10:30 am–11:00 am: Opening Session

    Welcoming Remarks

    Hoor Al Qasimi, President, Sharjah Art Foundation

    Introductory Remarks
    Salah M. Hassan, Director, Institute for Comparative Modernities, Cornell University, Ithaca

    Welcoming Remarks on Behalf of Frank Bowling and Family
    Benjamin Bowling - Professor of Criminology and Criminal Justice, King's College London

    11:00 am–12:30 pm: Session 1

    Between the Dream and its Materials: The Art of Frank Bowling
    Gilane Tawadros - Chief Executive, Design and Artists Copyright Society, London

    Some Thoughts on Artists & Abstraction
    Kellie Jones - Professor, Department of Art History and Archaeology, Columbia University, New York

    Discussant: Zoe Whitley - Curator, International Art, Tate Modern, London

    Moderator: Salah M. Hassan - Director, Institute for Comparative Modernities, Cornell University, Ithaca

    12:30 pm–2:00 pm: Lunch

    2:15 pm–3:45 pm: Session 2

    ‘Disregard’: Tom Lloyd and the Art of Refraction

    Krista Thompson - Professor, Department of Art History, Northwestern University, Evanston, US

    To be Young, Gifted, and Black: Reflections on Gender and ‘Soul of a Nation’
    Zoe Whitley - Curator, International Art, Tate Modern, London

    Discussant: Kellie Jones - Professor, Department of Art History and Archaeology, Columbia University, New York

    Moderator: Hoor Al Qasimi - President, Sharjah Art Foundation

    3:45 pm–4:00 pm: Break

    4:00 pm–5:30 pm: Remembering 5-plus-1 Roundtable

    Courtney J. Martin - Deputy Director and Chief Curator, Dia Art Foundation, New York

    Melvin Edwards - Sculptor

    Frank Bowling – Painter (participating remotely)

    5:30 pm: Closing Remarks
    Salah M. Hassan - Goldwin Smith Professor and Director, Institute for Comparative Modernities, Cornell University, Ithaca, US

Related Content

5-plus-1: Rethinking Abstraction

Bowling, Frank

For over five decades, Frank Bowling has incorporated both autobiography and postcolonial geopolitics into his work.